In partnership with CBSSports.com
Online Now 544
Online now 736 Record: 3990 (6/13/2012)
You have no favorite boards.
The most viewed topics.
The most replied to topics.
The most up-voted topics.
The most down-voted topics.
The most up-voted posters.
The most down-voted posters.
The most followed posters.
Starting a Bourbon collection to go along with my Scotch collection and I am looking for suggestions.
Here's what I have so far in my non mixer bourbon
Manhattan Baby Bourbon (technically not a bourbon, it was a gift)
Noahs Mill Small Batch
George T Stagg
Looking for some small batch suggestions
Really like Knob Creek, Hirsch and Jeffersons.
God needs a Safety on His team. RIP 21
It's not a small batch, but I really like Woodford Reserve.
I'm just starting to get into scotch. Any recommendations for something at a reasonable price?
Grangestone 12 yr. Total wine for $24 Inexpensive and pretty good single malt
Dalwhinnie 15 yr. Saw it for $50 @ Costco.
Coal Ila 12 yr. About $55, Islay Scotch. This is very similiar to Laphroaig and Lagavauln. Heavy peat.
Athens Townie is right on, grab any Pappy you can find. My girl bought me a bottle of the 20 year old for Christmas, she accidentally left the receipt in the pouch they provide - $157, and it's unbelievably smooth. The best bourbon I've ever tasted. I asked her to marry me less than a week later (true story, although have to admit it was already planned). It's impossible to find though and extremely price prohibitive in my case.
A few of my favorites:
Elmer T Lee Single Barrel - about $30 a bottle. One of the best imo, particularly at that price range
W.L. Weller 12 year old - about $25 a bottle. Great wheated bourbon at a nice price
Four Roses - I like most everything they do but if you can find a bottle of their 2012 Small Batch grab it. It's expensive, $70 a bottle, but it's worth it and would be a nice choice for your high end option. It's 110 proof so it'll knock you on your ass if you aren't careful.
you should give Rowan's Creek a run. It's mighty tasty!
Thx guys! Appreciate the suggestions. I'll continue the Van Winkle search, but in the mean time I'll try those that have been mentioned.
Top shelf- Booker's, Blanton's, and Jefferson's Reserve
Value- Ridgemont Reserve 1792 (this is my current favorite, love this stuff! If you like Knob Creek, you'll love this) and Buffalo Trace
"....All I ask is that he be loyal to Georgia, proud of that jersey, and try like the devil to win." --- Wally Butts
Blanton's hands down
These are 2 that I am sipping on right now. I have several more I will post tomorrow.
I agree weller and Elmer t lee hard to beat for the price. Pritchards, Parker's, Hirsch michters, I also agree the bookers bakers blantons, basil Hayden's all good. Next up for me is rock hill and whistle pig. Just my .02. Me likey bourbon....
This post was edited by Bourbon sipper 15 months ago
I would love a report on Whistle Pig. It seems to be "trendy" right now, especially the rye. But at the price they're asking, I have a hard time trusting a whiskey that ain't made down here. Vermont is awful close to Canada.
247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports